Daily Speculations

The Web Site of Victor Niederhoffer & Laurel Kenner

Dedicated to the scientific method, free markets, deflating ballyhoo, creating value, and laughter;  a forum for us to use our meager abilities to make the world of specinvestments a better place.

 

Home

Write to us at: (address is not clickable)

04/04
"Twilight Samurai"

Reviewed by Victor Niederhoffer and Laurel Kenner

A great movie in the line of the American gunfighter classic "Shane." Director Yoji Yamada portrays a brave, modest man who stands against the tide, offering speculators a model of character and individualism. The film is set in the 1860s toward the close of the Edo period; there is little call for sword-fighting, and the once-mighty samurai roam the countryside or work as ill-paid  clerks. The hero, Seibei, labors in a clan storehouse, where fellow workers nickname him "Twilight" because he declines their invitations to go out drinking. His wife's death from consumption -- and the lavish funeral demanded by her family -- left Seibei deeply in debt; he cares for his two young daughters and senile mother on his salary of 50 bales of rice a year, less 20 for debt repayment. The girls are ragged and dirty, but cheerful; Seibei is a devoted father and encourages them to learn the classics, once reserved only for men. Invited to come work as a guard in Kyoto, he declines. He wants to quit being a samurai and live as a farmer; unfortunately, the country is in a famine, and corpses of starved peasant children wash up on the riverbanks daily.

When his sunny, beautiful childhood sweetheart Tomoe returns to the village after a disastrous marriage, her visits brighten the lives of Seibei and his family; she cleans, sews, cooks, sings with the girls, takes them to festivals and is kind to the old mother. But Tomoe's jealous ex-husband, a samurai much larger than he is, challenges Seibei to a duel. Seibei's opponent, much taller than he is, arrives at the scene with a long samurai sword. Seibei deftly knocks him senseless using only a wooden stick, revealing himself as a formidable master of sword technique. He tries in vain to keep the incident secret; soon he is asked by his clan leader to kill another samurai, who has committed the crime of refusing to commit suicide for following a former leader's orders. It's a beautifully dramatic set-up for a conflict between tradition and change. Value vs. growth comes to mind (see Vic's 4/21 post below).

We have walked out of so many films lately -- the characters are invariably reprehensible, the businessman evil, the plot cynical and/or muddled -- that it's a pleasure to recommend a movie with admirable characters, a realistic portrayal of economic life and a positive, coherent point of view. As reviewer Bruce Fessler of The Desert Sun noted, the acting is so good that we don't know how the final scene will turn out.

 

For more movie reviews, click here