The Speculator's Corner
Looking for Tomorrow's Winners Among Today's Losers
By Laurel Kenner and Victor Niederhoffer

2/1/00 4:36 PM ET
URL: http://www.thestreet.com/comment/thespeculatorscorner/874539.html

Legendary London banker Nathan Rothschild said he liked to buy when the cannons were firing and sell when the trumpets were blowing. While the sound of January's cannons are still fresh in investors' minds, it may be a good time to survey the battlefield for bloodied stocks. After suffering two 10% corrections, the Nasdaq 100 offers a particularly wide assortment of attractive losers right now.

It's so much easier to tell friends about owning a winner than to admit to buying stocks that are down. When we overhear Manhattan dinner-table conversations, we inevitably hear lots of people talking about the big gains they had in JDS Uniphase (JDSU:Nasdaq) and Yahoo! (YHOO:Nasdaq). Nobody boasts about the awful mess they just bought.

But times like these remind us of the wisdom of titans of Wall Street like Henry Clews and Jesse Livermore. In his 1887 book Twenty-Eight Years in Wall Street, Clews notes that few gain enough experience in the market to command success "until they reach that period of life in which they have one foot in the grave." These old veterans, Clews wrote, spend periods at their comfortable homes. In times of panic, they can be seen hobbling on their canes to their brokers' offices, where they "buy good stocks to the extent of their bank balances, which have been permitted to accumulate for just such an emergency."

When the panic has dissipated, they quickly realize their profits, perhaps buying some choice real estate, and "retire for another season."

The expert timing of these hobblers comes from listening to the rhythms of the market. Last week, we mentioned one of our favorites musical pieces, Scott Joplin's Wall Street Rag. We like to remember that the section he called "Good Times Have Come" was preceded by the passage titled "Panic in Wall Street, Brokers Feeling Melancholy."

The canes probably saw much use in Monday's market when, at the bottom, it looked like the end of the world. Those who bought the S&P 500 March contract after it fell 0.7% from its open to its low were able to deposit considerable profits as it rallied a quick 44 points to 1401 from 1357. Anybody who bought futures or a related market basket saw a profit of about $10,000 per contract, or 3%, on their unleveraged holdings.

This is in accord with the 3% to 4% average rise in futures that has occurred immediately after panics in the past, as discussed in our Jan. 28 column. However, with individual Nasdaq stocks, the most effective strategy seems to be to hold them for a few months.

Looking at stocks in the Nasdaq 100 that had monthly declines of at least 30% last year, we discovered they tend to be lackluster in the subsequent month. But four months after the initial decline, we often find spectacular rises.

Two caveats are in order, however. First, our evidence is anecdotal and doesn't carry the weight of a comprehensive study. Second, these gains must be considered in the context of the 102% rise in the Nasdaq 100 from year-end 1998 to year-end 1999.

With that in mind, here's what we found.

The Nasdaq 100's Biggest Losers, by Month
Nasdaq 100 stocks that fell 30% or more in any given month during 1999.
Month Stock % Decline % change 1 month later % change, 4 months later
February 1999 Lycos -36% -1.8% +4.9%
3Com -33% -26 -15
March, 1999 Network Associates -35% -57 -43
April, 1999 Network Associates -57% +11 +27
Parametric Technology -34% +6.2 +7.2
May, 1999 Real Networks -36% -2.8 +48
Amazon.com -31% +5.4 +35
July, 1999 Starbucks -38% -1.6 +14
eBay -35% +29 +69
CNet -31% -6.1 +27
August, 1999 Global Crossing -38% +2.4 +93
Sept., 1999 Quintiles -47% -2.5 +39
Average -- -38% -3.6% +26%

This month's crop of losers may offer similar opportunities. Here are the five Nasdaq 100 stocks that fell at least 30% in January:

  • Legato Systems, -63%
  • BMC Software , -53%
  • Visx, -45%
  • Compuware , -43%
  • Synopsys, -31%

    Investors staying away from Nasdaq stocks after last year's 83% ascent and last month's turbulence could look at the S&P 500 and S&P Midcap.

    S&P 500 stocks that fell 30% or more:

  • Hercules, -39%
  • Rite Aid, -37%
  • Aon, -35%
  • Service Corp. International, -34%
  • Armstrong World, -31%
  • US Airways, -31%
  • (BMC Software and Compuware appear in both the S&P 500 and Nasdaq 100.)

    S&P Midcap Index that fell 30% or more:

  • AK Steel, -46%
  • Checkfree Holdings, -44%
  • Policy Management Systems, -38%
  • Sykes Enterprises, -37%
  • Quantum, -36%
  • Wallace Computer, -34%
  • Dial, -34%
  • PSS World Medical, -33%
  • Oregon Steel, -33%
  • Sotheby's, -32%
  • Williams-Sonoma, -31%
  • Total Renal Care, -31%
  • (Synopsys is part of both the Nasdaq 100 and S&P Midcap.)

    We hope those with canes parked in the closets find this useful.

    Speculator's Scorecard
    bearandbull
    # of Days Up
    (YTD)
    # of Days Down
    (YTD)
    # of Days in Latest Trend
    (up or down)
    % Change (YTD)
    Dow 10 10 Won 1 -5.1
    S&P 500 9 11 Won 1 -5.7
    Nasdaq 11 9 Won 1 -3.6
    DAX 10 11 Lost 2 1.3
    Nikkei 12 7 Won 4 3.2
    dollar/yen 9 10 Lost 2 -5.3
    dollar/euro 5 6 Lost 2 -0.1
    Gold 10 9 Won 1 -2.0
    Oil 12 7 Won 1 +12
    Bond 12 9 Lost 1 -1.5
    Bund 11 10 Won 2 -1.1
    Source: Carr Futures, Bloomberg


    Laurel Kenner is a trader and a former markets editor at Bloomberg. Former hedge fund manager Victor Niederhoffer is currently a private investor and author of Education of a Speculator. At time of publication, Niederhoffer held a net short position in S&P 500 futures and options, and owned Quintiles Transnational, while Kenner did not hold a position in any of the stocks mentioned in this column, although positions can change at any time. Under no circumstances does the information in this column represent a recommendation to buy or sell stocks. While they cannot provide investment advice or recommendations, they invite you to comment on this column at commentarymail@thestreet.com.


    © 2000 TheStreet.com, All Rights Reserved.